Before 11/2020, grades range from 5 to 3.5 stars. After that, grade range is: 10 (A+), 9.5 (high A), 9 (A), 8.5 (high A-), 8 (A-), 7.5 (high B+), and 7 (B+). Ungraded albums are noted as liked :-) (honorable mention), neutral :-|, and disliked :-(. At least 4 listens per graded album and 3 listens per ungraded album. Search "Grade Post" for more info. I sold/shelved ~10,000 albums after at least 3 or 4 listens, respectively, before starting this blog and will add entries for those as they arise.
Sunday, June 11, 2023
Saturday, June 10, 2023
Water From Your Eyes - Everyone's Crushed: 7 (B+)
Coulson, Dean, McGuiness, Flint - Lo & Behold: 8 (A-)
I originally had this at 7.5 (high B+) and #covers but ended up with a vinyl copy for some reason. Presumably that means I begrudgingly consider it an 8 (A-). Maybe I was swayed by Christgau's continued support for it at full A. Update (September 2026): I just found a CD version of this on my final listen shelf, so I guess I have it in two formats. I'll put the vinyl in the sell pile.
Tom Robinson - North by Northwest: 8 (A-)
Joy Division - Still: 7.5 (high B+)
Originally released as a vinyl double album in 1981, this was problematic from the start. The first album was necessary outtakes and other studio material, but the second album was a completely unnecessary live set. This original version was later reissued on CD as a first generation CD transfer, which I normally avoid. Then it was re-rereleased as a 2CD set, with the original double album on the first CD, and a second CD with a further unnecessary live set. I'm not buying a padded outtake album in used vinyl, when it was reissued on CD, not buying the reissued CD because it's not remastered, and not buying the bloated 2-CD version. In this case, the outtakes disc is good enough that I was tempted to just buy the original CD version, but it's selling used for more than the bloated 2-CD set sells new. Ridiculous. I did find a like-new original CD selling for a reasonable price, but of course it's a cut-out, so the price is actually not that reasonable. Bottom line: I'll stick with the two studio albums and Substance.
p.s., I was tempted to manufacture a single CD of the first album of the original release, with the studio material. That would be, leaving off the live "Sister Ray" and the tracks that are on Substance ("Glass" and "Dead Souls"). But what's the point of that anymore, especially for seven outtakes? Note also that Christgau and Hull didn't even review the release. Update (November 2025): I was buying something for a great price online, but there was a minimum order requirement, and I decided to finally get the reissued CD after all because I saw if for a fantastic price, which I probably would have paid on its own anyway, and so now I have a copy (as well as a copy of the 2CD re-release, somehow!).
Sunday, June 4, 2023
Kabaka International Guitar Band - Kabaka International Guitar Band: 7.5 (high B+)
Saturday, June 3, 2023
Tom Robinson Band - batch review
Jon Langford - batch review
The Pine Valley Cosmonauts - The Executioner's Last Songs
Waco Brothers - Cowboy in Flames
Waco Brothers - Wacoworld
Waco Brothers - Electric Waco Chair



















