Diary of a Melomaniac
Before 11/2020, grades range from 5 to 3.5 stars. After that, grade range is: 10 (A+), 9.5 (high A), 9 (A), 8.5 (high A-), 8 (A-), 7.5 (high B+), and 7 (B+). Ungraded albums are noted as liked :-) (honorable mention), neutral :-|, and disliked :-(. At least 4 listens per graded album and 3 listens per ungraded album. Search "Grade Post" for more info. I sold/shelved ~10,000 albums after at least 3 or 4 listens, respectively, before starting this blog and will add entries for those as they arise.
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Galaxie 500 - Uncollected [Rykodisc, 2004]: liked
The final disc of the box set Galaxie 500 on the same label, according to AllMusic. I did not do a comparison myself. Perhaps a 7 (B+), but it's #miscarticles anyway.
Beat Happening - Jamboree [Rough Trade/K, 1988]: liked
Could be a 7 (B+) if I stretched it, and I might even do so and buy it for impact (eg, it's #33 on the Pitchfork list The 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time), but it’s selling for stupid high prices, especially for 23 minutes of music (really an EP, except for the fact that it's divided into 11 tracks, so it escapes that as an official designation), so, I’ll pass. Btw, they should definitely have left off the atrocious final track, and made it only 20 minutes long
Rick Danko - Times Like These [Breeze Hill, 2000]: liked
Love that voice, and the man, frankly. See you in heaven, if I get there, which I probably won't.
MJ Lenderman - Boat Songs [Dear Life, 2022]: liked
Played, among other reasons, because it was #79 on Pitchfork's list The 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time. Five or six plays.
Duster - Stratosphere [Up, 1998]: liked
Played because it was #76 on Pitchfork's list The 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time. Four plays.
Alex G - House of Sugar [Domino, 2019]: liked
Played because it was #53 on Pitchfork's list The 100 Best Indie Rock Albums of All Time, which should be re-titled The 100 Best Semi-Unpopular Albums of All Time (note: compiled by people who are too young to have lived through the entire indie era).
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Sebadoh - batch review
As per usual, I have had these for years, and will give them grades as I play them again in the future, but they are obviously all at least a 7 (B+), and possibly as high as 9 (A), or maybe even a 9.5 (high A) (Bakesale?):
Harmacy
The Sebadoh
Bakesale
Built to Spill - batch review
I will post on these issues as I replay them going forward, but for now they are all "on the shelves," which usually means at least 7 (B+), but I am a completist with this band, which is one of my favorites, so that might not hold in every case. Probably does though.
Built to Spill Caustic Resin [split EP]
You in Reverse
Ancient Melodies of the Future
Live
Keep It Like a Secret
Perfect From Now On
There's Nothing Wrong With Love
Saturday, November 14, 2026
Jocelyn Balu - Borumba: 7 (B+)
Marred by always cheesy keybs and sometimes cheesy melodies. The lead guitar is uniformly great though. #import/nophysicals?
Brian Jackson - Now More Than Ever: liked
It would almost certainly be a 7 (B+) upon one more play, but I’d dock it a notch for extreme bloat anyway, so I'm not putting in the effort. Also, it's #r&b.
The Brian Jonestown Massacre - Take It From the Man!: 7.5 (high B+)
Docked a notch for bloat. I would get a copy, but they are so ridiculously overpriced that I’m not going to even bother with an alert at this grade. The best songs on here are also on Tepid Peppermint Wonderland anyway (seven out of this one’s 17 unique tracks are on that compilation, so close to half).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)












